A honeybee covered in yellow pollen on a flower

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE · CHAPTER 7

Extinction Evidence

Follow along with your worksheet, one question at a time.

mrsajdak.com/extinction

Photo: Jon Sullivan, public domain

OPTION A · VIDEO

Forty Million Almond Trees

Clip 1 is PBS on pollinating 40 million almond trees. Clip 2 is an AP news report on colonies collapsing. Clip 3 is rare footage of a wild bee, the rusty patched bumble bee, from Clean Wisconsin.

Watch for

How do the almond flowers get pollinated?

What did beekeepers find when they opened their hives?

Clip 3: is this wild bee in more danger than the honeybee? Why might that be?

Next: Observe, wonder, predict →

CLIP 0:00 TO 2:00

Open on YouTube

Videos on YouTube: PBS; AP Archive; Clean Wisconsin.

OPTION B · TRY IT · 4 MINUTES

Breakfast Without Bees

1

Get a food card with a partner.

2

Cross out every food that needs bees or other insects to carry pollen.

3

Circle the foods that grow without them.

4

Count what is left. Would you want to eat this way?

Next: Observe, wonder, predict →

You need

One food card per pair (apples, almonds, blueberries, cranberries, cucumbers, cherries, pumpkins, watermelon, wheat bread, rice, corn, oatmeal)

A pencil

Watch for

Most fruits and nuts need bees.

Wheat, rice, corn and oats are grains. They do not need insects: wind or their own flowers do the job.

What would a grocery store look like with far fewer bees?

OPTION C · PHOTOS

Phenomenon: Two Bees

A honeybee covered in yellow pollen on a flower

Photo A. A honeybee, covered in pollen.

A rusty patched bumble bee on a purple wild bergamot flower

Photo B. A rusty patched bumble bee, a wild bee.

Photos: Jon Sullivan, public domain · Jill Utrup, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, public domain

START HERE

Observe, wonder, predict

Each winter, U.S. beekeepers open their hives and find 30 to 45 out of every 100 colonies gone. The bees just vanish.

OBSERVEWhat is the bee in Photo A carrying? Where is it?

WONDERWhat do you wonder about where the bees went?

PREDICTWhich bee is more likely to go extinct? Why?

A honeybee covered in yellow pollen on a flower

Photo A. A honeybee.

A rusty patched bumble bee on a purple wild bergamot flower

Photo B. A rusty patched bumble bee.

Photos: Jon Sullivan, public domain · Jill Utrup, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, public domain

DRIVING QUESTION

What makes a species disappear, and is it happening faster now?

START HERE

What Happened Here?

Finished observing? Click here to find out.

Honeybee colonies are collapsing: mites, viruses, pesticides, fewer wildflowers and the stress of being trucked from farm to farm all play a part, and they work together. But beekeepers replace lost hives, so honeybees are not close to extinction. The wild rusty patched bumble bee has no keepers. It was listed as endangered in 2017.

Watched the video or tried it? Click here.

Bees carry pollen from flower to flower, so plants can make fruit and seeds. Bee pollination adds more than $15 billion a year to U.S. crops, and bees pollinate about one-third of the U.S. food supply. Grains like wheat and rice do not need them.

Today, you will read the evidence for five mass extinctions in the rocks. You will compare real counts of animals lost since 1900 with the natural rate. Then you will shrink a habitat in a model and see who wins and who loses.

BEFORE YOU START

What you will learn

I can

explain how a change in environmental conditions can drive a species to extinction.

I can

compare the background extinction rate with the rate since 1900.

I can

tell an endangered species from a threatened one and name traits that put a species at risk.

BEFORE YOU START

Get set up

1

Do the Do Now at the top of your sheet.

2

Open mrsajdak.com/extinction.

3

Keep your pencil and your sheet beside you.

4

Everything you pick goes in a log. Copy from the log.

The lab: a timeline of the last 500 million years with five bars for the mass extinctions

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/extinction, Tab 1

The Palisades, tall gray cliffs along the Hudson River

TAB 1 · QUESTIONS 1 TO 6

Part 1. The Big Five

These cliffs on the Hudson River are lava rock.

They cooled from giant eruptions 201 million years ago, when most species on Earth died.

Photo: Beyond My Ken, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 1 TO 3

Five mass extinctions

1

Tap a bar on the timeline.

2

Read what changed, and look at the fossil.

3

Copy the row into Question 1.

4

Do all five.

LIVE LAB · TAB 1

New tab

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 3

How a species goes extinct

Every species fits the conditions where it lives.

When the conditions change, some members cannot survive or have young.

If no members can adapt and reproduce, the species is extinct. Gone for good.

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 3

Five times, the whole planet changed

You logged five mass extinctions. In each one, about 75% to 90% of species died.

Each came after a global change in conditions: an ice age, oceans that lost their oxygen, giant volcanoes, an asteroid.

Cause and effect: the conditions changed first. Then the species died.

A trilobite fossil in gray rock

Photo: Diego Delso, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 3

After a mass extinction

Some species survive. Over time they fill the empty places to live.

After the dinosaurs died 66 million years ago, mammals spread out into many new kinds.

But each recovery took several million years.

Tyrannosaurus skeletons in a museum hall

Photo: author unknown, public domain

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 4 TO 6

Cause, then effect

QUESTION 4

2 words

Name it

Every member gone.

Many species, a short time.

QUESTION 5

2 verbs

Why a species ends

What can the members not do

when conditions change?

QUESTION 6

Recovery

After the dinosaurs

Who spread out?

How long did it take?

A black and white photo of a thylacine, a striped wolf-like animal, in a zoo

TAB 2 · QUESTIONS 7 TO 11

Part 2. How fast now?

The last thylacine died in a zoo in 1936.

Is that normal? How many species should we expect to lose?

Photo: Harry Burrell, public domain

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 7 AND 8

Animals lost since 1900

1

Tap each animal group.

2

Each red dot is one species gone since 1900.

3

Each green dot is one species we would expect to lose.

4

Copy the numbers into Question 7.

LIVE LAB · TAB 2

New tab

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 3

The background extinction rate

Species have always gone extinct, a few at a time. That slow, natural rate is the background extinction rate.

Scientists used a generous background rate here: 2 species lost per million species per year.

At that rate, about 9 of the 39,223 animals checked should have gone extinct since 1900.

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 3

How many times faster?

To compare, divide what happened by what was expected.

Example, mammals: 35 lost ÷ 1.3 expected = about 27 times faster than the background rate.

Now do the same for birds and for all the groups together.

A black and white photo of a thylacine, a striped wolf-like animal, in a zoo

Photo: Harry Burrell, public domain

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 3

A sixth mass extinction?

The textbook says species are now going extinct at least 1,000 times the natural rate.

If that keeps up, Earth is entering a sixth mass extinction.

The first five came from natural changes. This one is driven mostly by people changing conditions, and it could happen in one human lifetime.

PART 2 · QUESTION 9

How many times faster?

1

Find the number lost since 1900.

2

Find the number expected.

3

Divide lost by expected.

Example

A town expects 2 house fires a year.

It had 30.

30 ÷ 2

= 15 times as many

These are not your numbers. Use your own.

The lab graph: red bars for species lost and green bars for species expected, for each group visited

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/extinction, Tab 2

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 9 TO 11

Faster than normal

QUESTION 9

÷

Times faster

Birds.

All five groups.

QUESTION 10

Rate

The natural rate

Name it.

How long should the losses have taken?

QUESTION 11

Answer

A friend’s claim

"Extinction is a thing of the past."

Use one number.

A mother orangutan and her baby in a tree

TAB 3 · QUESTIONS 12 TO 16

Part 3. Who wins, who loses?

Forests are cleared for farms, roads and towns.

Does every species lose when its habitat shrinks?

Photo: Thomas Fuhrmann, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 3 · QUESTIONS 12 AND 13

Shrink the habitat

1

Pick 40%. Press Run 30 years.

2

Watch the bars and the graph.

3

Pick 60% and run it again.

4

Copy both runs into Question 12.

LIVE LAB · TAB 3

New tab

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 3

Not every species loses

When the habitat shrank, the deer and raccoons went up. They are generalists. They use farms, yards and forest edges.

The other four went down. A change in conditions can help some species and push others toward extinction.

A raccoon in Central Park, New York City

Photo: Rhododendrites, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 3

Traits that raise the risk

Low reproductive rate: few young. An orangutan has one baby about every 8 years.

Specialized niche: needs one thing. Karner blue caterpillars eat only wild lupine.

Requires a large territory: needs a lot of room. A Florida panther roams hundreds of square miles.

In the model, more risk traits meant a bigger drop. Large-territory species vanished once less than half their habitat was left.

A mother orangutan and her baby in a tree

Photo: Thomas Fuhrmann, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 3

Endangered or threatened?

Scientists track each species' numbers, its range and its habitat needs. The IUCN Red List is the world list.

In this lab: down 30% to 49% = threatened. Down 50% or more = endangered.

When a species is lost, what it does is lost too. Orangutans spread the seeds of hundreds of rain forest plants.

PART 3 · QUESTIONS 14 TO 16

Traits make the difference

QUESTION 14

2 words

Threatened or endangered?

Falling, but enough for now.

So few it could soon be gone.

QUESTION 15

Traits

Name the trait

Eats only one plant.

One baby every 8 years.

QUESTION 16

Model

Simpler than real life

Name one way.

How could it change the results?

WRAP IT UP · QUESTION 17

Evaluate the evidence

Claim: "A change in environmental conditions can drive species toward extinction."

1. What changed?

2. What happened to the species?

3. Did the change come first, in the same place and time?

Then decide: the evidence supports the claim, or it does not.

A small Karner blue butterfly on a green leaf

Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, CC BY 2.0

WRAP IT UP · BACK TO THE START

Revisiting the Phenomenon

What makes a species disappear, and is it happening faster now?

EVIDENCE

The rocks

What came before every mass extinction?

EVIDENCE

The counts

How does the rate since 1900 compare with the natural rate?

EVIDENCE

The model

Which kind of species won when the habitat shrank? Which lost?

Back to the bees: which one is in more danger, the honeybee or the wild bumble bee? Use a trait to say why.

Hand in your worksheet.

Check your name, date and period.