The Horseshoe Falls seen from the air, a white curtain of water curving around a cloud of mist, with a tour boat below

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE · WATER AND ENERGY

Niagara River Current Lab

Follow along with your worksheet, one question at a time.

mrsajdak.com/niagara

Photo: Thomaswm, CC BY-SA 4.0

START HERE

Phenomenon: One Cliff, Two Days

A black and white photo taken across a river. A long rock cliff stands bare and dry above a pile of huge broken boulders. City buildings stand behind it.

Photo A. A cliff in Niagara Falls, New York, one summer.

A colour photo of the same cliff from the same side of the river. A wide waterfall pours over it into a cloud of mist. The same city buildings stand behind it.

Photo B. The same cliff, another summer.

Photos: NMGiovannucci, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Ken Lund, CC BY-SA 2.0

START HERE

Observe, wonder, predict

These photographs show the same cliff from across the river. In one, a river pours over it. In the other, the rock is dry. This river drains four of the five Great Lakes. Where could that much water go?

OBSERVEWhat differences do you notice between the photographs?

WONDERWhere might the water have gone?

PREDICTCan people control how much water goes over a waterfall this big? Explain your reasoning.

A satellite map of the Niagara River, drawn in bright colours, running from Lake Erie at the bottom to Lake Ontario at the top

The Niagara River runs from Lake Erie (bottom) to Lake Ontario (top). The falls are near the middle.

Map: mrsajdak.com/niagara

DRIVING QUESTION

Who decides how much water goes over Niagara Falls, and where does the rest of the river go?

START HERE

What Happened Here?

Finished observing? Click here to find out.

In June 1969, the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers built a temporary dam of rock and earth across the river above the American Falls. For about five months the water went around the other side of Goat Island, and the American Falls stood dry. Engineers walked on the riverbed and studied the rock. In November 1969 they took the dam out, and the water came back.

Today, you will investigate the whole Niagara River, not just the falls. You will measure it at six places, find out where its water goes, and ride it from one Great Lake to the next. At the end of the investigation, you will return to the driving question.

BEFORE YOU START

Five things you can measure

Width

How far it is across the river, bank to bank. In meters (m).

Depth

How far down to the riverbed. The lab gives the average.

Speed

How fast the water moves, in meters per second (m/s).

Area

The size of the cut across the river. Area = width × depth, in m².

Flow

How much water passes each second. Flow = area × speed, in m³/s.

A drawing of the river cut across at the Peace Bridge: a wide, shallow band of water coloured by speed, with a depth scale down the side

The river cut open at one station. You are looking downstream. The coloured shape is the area.

1 m³ of water is 1,000 liters. It weighs as much as a small car.

BEFORE YOU START

What you will learn

I can use width, depth and speed to explain why a river runs fast in some places and slow in others.

I can use flow numbers to weigh the costs and benefits of sending river water through power plants.

BEFORE YOU START

Get set up

1

Open mrsajdak.com/niagara on your device.

2

Write your name, the date and your period on the worksheet.

3

Get a calculator. Your phone or your device has one.

4

Find the three tabs at the top of the lab. Each tab goes with one part of the worksheet.

5

Start on Tab 1. Do not skip ahead.

The top of the lab page, showing the title and three tabs: Measure the river, Share the water, Ride the river
Tab in the labWorksheetQuestions
1. Measure the riverPart 11 to 6
2. Share the waterPart 27 to 11
3. Ride the riverPart 3 and Wrap it up12 to 16

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara

A long steel bridge with five arches crossing a wide blue river

TAB 1 · QUESTIONS 1 TO 6

Part 1. Measure the river

The river is not the same shape everywhere. It is wide here, narrow there, shallow here, deep there.

You will measure it at six stations. Watch what the shape does to the speed.

Photo: Óðinn, CC BY-SA 3.0

PART 1 · TAB 1

Pick a station

1

Find Pick a station. Press 1. Peace Bridge.

2

The map flies there. The yellow line is your station. It goes bank to bank.

3

Read the three numbers under Station 1: width, average depth, average speed.

4

Colour shows speed. Blue is slow. Red and purple are fast.

5

You can also tap the water anywhere to read that one spot.

The lab map zoomed in on the Peace Bridge, with a yellow line across the river and the water coloured yellow, orange and red

Lake Erie is at the bottom of the map. The water runs north, up the screen.

The Pick a station list in the lab, with six numbered stations

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTION 1

Three numbers in, two numbers out

1

Copy the width, average depth and average speed for the station.

2

Multiply width × depth. That is the area.

3

Multiply area × speed. That is the flow.

4

Round area and flow to the nearest whole number.

5

Do all six stations.

The measurement boxes in the lab: width in meters, average depth in meters, average speed in meters per second The Your measurements table in the lab, with a row for each station measured

Example

Width 200 m. Depth 5 m. Speed 2 m/s.

1,000 × 2 = 2,000 m³/s

Area = 200 × 5 = 1,000 m².

These are not your numbers. Use your own.

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 2 AND 3

Look at the size of the cut

The river cut across at the pool below the falls: a narrow but very deep shape, coloured dark blue

Station 4, the pool below the falls.

The river cut across at the Whirlpool Rapids: a very small shape, coloured purple

Station 5, the Whirlpool Rapids. Same scale.

QUESTION 2

Fastest and slowest

Look down your speed column. Write the station and its speed.

QUESTION 3

Area and speed

Find the area of your fastest station and your slowest station.

What happens to the speed when the cut gets smaller?

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 1

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Water is not used up

Matter is not made or destroyed: conservation of matter. If two lines pass the same flow, no water was lost between them.

A satellite map of the Niagara River, drawn in bright colours, running from Lake Erie at the bottom to Lake Ontario at the top

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 1

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Area and speed trade off

Flow = area × speed. The same flow through a smaller area means faster water. A bigger area means slower water.

The river cut across at the Whirlpool Rapids: a very small shape, coloured purple for fast water

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 1

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Think of a crowd

The same number of people must leave a stadium each minute. In a wide hall they stroll. At a narrow gate they hurry.

White, churning rapids running down the bottom of a deep rock gorge in autumn

Photo: Jim.henderson, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Width is not everything

Area is width × depth. A wide but shallow river can have a small area. A narrow but deep one can have a huge area.

The river cut across at the pool below the falls: a narrow but very deep shape, coloured dark blue

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 4 TO 6

Follow the water

QUESTION 4

2 + 3

Around the island

Stations 2 and 3 are the two sides of Grand Island. Add their flows and compare with Station 1.

Use conservation of matter to explain.

QUESTION 5

4 → 5

Crawl, then race

The same water passes Station 4, then Station 5.

Use flow = area × speed and their areas to explain the change in speed.

QUESTION 6

?

Something is missing

Compare the flow at Stations 1 and 6 with Stations 4 and 5.

How much is missing? Predict where it went.

A huge concrete power plant built into the wall of a river gorge, with green water flowing out from its base

TAB 2 · QUESTIONS 7 TO 11

Part 2. Share the water

Above the falls, tunnels and a canal take water out of the river.

It comes back here, at the power plants, 7 km downstream.

Photo: Busfahrer, CC BY 3.0

PART 2 · TAB 2

Two countries, one river

DAYTIME

2,832

m³/s over the falls

In 1950 the United States and Canada signed a treaty. By day in tourist season, the falls must get at least this much.

OVERNIGHT

1,850

m³/s over the falls

At night and in winter the treaty lets the plants take more. This is what the gauge usually reads at night.

THE REST

0.8 MW

for each m³/s

The rest goes through the power plants. Each cubic meter per second makes about 0.8 megawatts.

PART 2 · QUESTION 7

Daytime, then overnight

1

Press Daytime.

2

Copy three numbers from Where the water goes: over the falls, through the plants, electric power.

3

Find Station 5 in The stations at this setting. Copy its depth and speed.

4

Work out the percent through the plants.

5

Press Overnight. Do it all again.

The Where the water goes box in the lab: flow leaving Lake Erie, over the falls and through the power plants, with electric power and homes
The stations table in the lab, with depth, speed and flow for each of the six stations

Example

2,900 ÷ 5,800 × 100 = 50%

2,900 through the plants.

These are not your numbers. Use your own.

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 2

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Water takes a shortcut

Above the falls, intakes pull water out. Tunnels carry it around the falls to the power plants. It rejoins the river just above Lewiston.

The lab map from the falls to the power plants, with dashed yellow lines from the power intakes above the falls to the power plants downstream

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 2

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Energy changes form

High water has potential energy. Falling 90 m, it gains kinetic energy. It spins a turbine, and a generator makes electrical energy.

A huge concrete power plant built into the wall of a river gorge, with green water flowing out from its base

Photo: Busfahrer, CC BY 3.0

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

More water, more power

1 m³/s falling 90 m gives about 0.9 MW. The plants turn about 9 parts in 10 into electricity: about 0.8 MW. Twice the water, twice the power.

The Where the water goes box in the lab: flow leaving Lake Erie, over the falls and through the power plants, with electric power and homes

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 2

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Costs and benefits

A 1950 treaty keeps 2,832 m³/s on the falls by day. Water power burns no fuel. But water sent to the plants skips the falls and the gorge.

The Horseshoe Falls seen from the air, a white curtain of water curving around a cloud of mist, with a tour boat below

Photo: Thomaswm, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 8 AND 9

Where it leaves, where it comes back

The lab map from the falls to the power plants, with dashed yellow lines from the power intakes above the falls to the power plants downstream

Dashed lines: the tunnels and canals, drawn straight.

A bar graph of the flow passing each of the six stations. Stations 4 and 5 are much shorter than stations 1 and 6

QUESTION 8

Why do only two stations change?

Find the power intakes and the power plants on the map. Which stations are in between?

QUESTION 9

A shallower gorge

Subtract the overnight depth at the rapids from the daytime depth. Who would notice?

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 2

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 10 AND 11

Your turn at the controls

1

Drag the Water over the falls slider all the way to the right. Nothing goes to the plants.

2

Copy the power, the homes and the speed at Station 5.

3

Drag it all the way to the left. The plants take all they can.

4

Copy the same numbers.

5

Question 11: check the daytime power with a calculator.

QUESTION 11

Check the power, then follow the energy

Multiply the daytime flow through the plants by 0.8. Do you get the lab's MW?

Use potential energy, kinetic energy and electrical energy to tell what happens to the water's energy.

White, churning rapids running down the bottom of a deep rock gorge in autumn

TAB 3 · QUESTIONS 12 TO 15

Part 3. Ride the river

Ten floats start in a row across the river.

Each one goes where its water goes. Not all of them get to Lake Ontario.

Photo: Jim.henderson, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 3 · QUESTION 12

Release the floats

1

Pick Daytime. Press Release 10 floats.

2

Watch for a while. Zoom in on the falls to see where they split up.

3

Press Skip to the end.

4

Count the floats in each place. Use Where each float ended.

5

Pick Overnight and do it again.

The lab map above the falls with numbered, coloured floats riding the current toward the falls and the power intakes

Each float starts with one tenth of the river behind it.

The Where each float ended table in the lab, listing ten floats, where each one ended and how many hours it took

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 3

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Floats are tracers

Scientists drop floats or dye in a river to see where its water goes. A tracer goes wherever its water goes.

The lab map above the falls with numbered, coloured floats riding the current toward the falls and the power intakes

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 3

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Small samples are rough

Flip a coin 10 times: you might get 4 or 7 heads, not 5. Flip it 1,000 times and you get close to half. Ten floats are a small sample.

The Where each float ended table in the lab, listing ten floats, where each one ended and how many hours it took

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 3

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Average speed

Average speed = total distance ÷ total time, for the whole trip. It does not care how fast the fastest part was.

A line graph of distance against time for each float. Lines for floats that reach Lake Ontario climb to about 52 kilometers

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 3

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Slow parts take the most time

10 km at 60 km/h takes 10 minutes. 2 km of traffic jam at 6 km/h takes 20 minutes. 12 km in 30 minutes is only 24 km/h.

A long steel bridge with five arches crossing a wide blue river

Photo: Óðinn, CC BY-SA 3.0

PART 3 · QUESTION 13

Floats and water

QUESTION 13

Should they match?

Compare your last column in Question 12 with the percent through the plants in Question 7.

Use tracers to explain why the two should be close.

Use sample size to explain why they are not exactly the same.

The Where each float ended table in the lab, listing ten floats, where each one ended and how many hours it took

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 3

PART 3 · QUESTION 14

Time one float, stretch by stretch

1

Go back to Daytime and press Skip to the end.

2

Copy the Checkpoint times table: hours and distance.

3

For each stretch, subtract to get the km and the hours.

4

Speed = km ÷ hours.

A line graph of distance against time for each float. Lines for floats that reach Lake Ontario climb to about 52 kilometers

A steep line is a fast float.

Example

At hour 1.0 a float is at 2.0 km.

At hour 3.0 it is at 12.0 km.

10.0 ÷ 2.0 = 5 km/h

That is 10.0 km in 2.0 hours.

These are not your numbers. Use your own.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 3

PART 3 · QUESTION 15

Fast water, slow trip

QUESTION 15

The gorge is not as fast as it looks

The gorge has the fastest station on the river.

But your float's average speed through the whole gorge was not much higher than anywhere else.

Look at Station 4 in your Part 1 table. What does the float do there?

The river cut across at the pool below the falls: a very deep shape coloured dark blue for slow water

Station 4 is in the gorge too.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/niagara, Tab 1

WRAP IT UP · QUESTION 16

How would you share the river?

One side

“Send it all over the falls. It is a natural wonder.”

Other side

“Send more to the power plants. The electricity is made without burning fuel.”

Your choice

Pick a number of m³/s for the falls. Back it with at least two numbers from Part 2.

The cost

Every choice costs something. Name one cost of yours.

The American Falls pouring over a rock cliff into mist, with city buildings behind

The American Falls on a September day.

Photo: Ken Lund, CC BY-SA 2.0

WRAP IT UP · BACK TO THE START

Revisiting the Phenomenon

Who decides how much water goes over Niagara Falls, and where does the rest of the river go?

1Who decides how much water goes over Niagara Falls? What evidence from the lab shows it?

2Where does the rest of the river go, and where does it come back? Use station numbers.

3In 1969 the American Falls was dry, but the river kept flowing. Use what you know about flow to explain where that water went.

4Tonight the falls will carry less water than at noon. Which numbers from your Question 7 table show this?

White rapids at the bottom of a deep rock gorge

LAST CHECK

Before you hand it in

Name, date and period are on top.

All six tables are full.

Every flow and speed has its unit.

Question 16 has two numbers and one cost.

Photo: Jim.henderson, CC BY-SA 4.0