A sea otter floating on its back in calm water

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE · CHAPTER 5

Sea Otters and Kelp Lab

Follow along with your worksheet, one question at a time.

mrsajdak.com/otters

Photo: Mike Baird, CC BY 2.0

START HERE

Phenomenon: Two Reefs, One Coast

Underwater on a rocky reef. Tall golden-brown seaweed rises from the bottom toward the sunlit surface, with fish swimming between the stalks.

Photo A. A rocky reef in cold, shallow water.

Underwater on a rocky reef. Dozens of spiny purple animals sit side by side on bare rock. There is no tall seaweed.

Photo B. Another rocky reef on the same coast.

Photos: Robert Schwemmer, NOAA · Ed Bierman, CC BY 2.0

START HERE

Observe, wonder, predict

These photos show two rocky reefs on the same coast. The water is just as cold at both. The rock is the same kind. One reef is full of tall seaweed and fish. The other is almost bare. How can two reefs that start out so alike end up so different?

OBSERVEWhat differences do you notice between the two reefs?

WONDERWhy might the tall seaweed be missing from one reef?

PREDICTWould the bare reef change if one new kind of animal moved in? Explain your reasoning.

DRIVING QUESTION

How can losing one animal change a whole ecosystem?

START HERE

What Is Going On Here?

Finished observing? Click here to find out.

Both photos were taken by divers off the coast of southern California. Photo A is from Channel Islands National Marine Sanctuary. The tall seaweed is giant kelp. Photo B is from the Ventura area, on the same stretch of coast. The purple animals are sea urchins. Both kinds of reef exist along this coast, sometimes only a few miles apart.

Today, you will investigate what lives on two different seafloors, what happens to a coast when one kind of animal is added or taken away, and how scientists track a real population over many years. At the end of the investigation, you will use your own counts and model runs to explain these two reefs and return to the original driving question.

BEFORE YOU START

Who eats whom

A sea otter holding a purple sea urchin in its paws

Sea otter

Eats sea urchins.

eats

Purple sea urchins in a rocky tide pool

Sea urchin

Eats kelp.

eats

Tall kelp plants seen from below with sunlight coming through

Kelp

Makes its food from sunlight.

Otters never eat kelp. So why would kelp need otters?

Photos: matt knoth, CC BY 2.0 · James St. John, CC BY 2.0 · NOAA Photo Library

BEFORE YOU START

Two seafloors

A thick kelp forest reaching up toward the surface

Kelp forest

Thick kelp. Few urchins.

Many sea urchins on bare rock with almost no kelp left

Urchin barren

Bare rock. Urchins everywhere.

Same kind of rocky reef. Today you find out what makes the difference.

Photos: NOAA Photo Library, Channel Islands · Shaun Lee, CC BY 4.0, New Zealand

BEFORE YOU START

What you will learn

I can explain why the sea otter is a keystone species in a kelp forest.

I can use the southern sea otter case study to ask a testable question about what controls a population.

BEFORE YOU START

Get set up

1

Open mrsajdak.com/otters on your device.

2

Write your name, the date and your period on the worksheet.

3

Find the three tabs at the top of the lab. Each tab goes with one part of the worksheet.

4

Start on Tab 1. Do not skip ahead.

The top of the lab page, showing the title and three tabs: Survey the seafloor, Keystone coast, California comeback
Tab in the labWorksheetQuestions
1. Survey the seafloorPart 11 to 5
2. Keystone coastPart 26 to 9
3. California comebackPart 3 and Wrap it up10 to 16

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters

A scuba diver on the seafloor counting inside a square frame called a quadrat

TAB 1 · QUESTIONS 1 TO 5

Part 1. Survey the seafloor

A quadrat is a square frame, 1 m on each side. Divers set it on the seafloor and count what is inside.

You will count 10 quadrats on each of two islands.

Photo: Olivier Dugornay, Ifremer, CC BY 4.0

PART 1 · TAB 1

Count a quadrat

1

Pick Island A. Start with quadrat 1.

2

Tap every purple urchin inside the white square.

3

Tap every kelp plant. Tap the dark knot in the middle. That is its holdfast.

4

Check the tally. Press Record this quadrat.

5

Count two quadrats by hand on each island. Then you may press Count the rest of this island for me.

The lab screen for Island A, quadrat 1: a map of the transect on the left and the quadrat on the right with four kelp plants circled

A white ring means you marked it. Tap again to undo. Rocks do not count.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTION 1

Fill in your data table

1

Find the Your data box in the lab.

2

Copy all 40 counts onto your worksheet.

3

Add up each column. Write the total.

4

Find each average per m². Divide the total by 10.

5

Press Show averages to check your math.

The Your data box in the lab: a table with rows for quadrats 1 to 10, a total row and an average row, for urchins and kelp on Island A and Island B

Example

A column adds up to 40 urchins in 10 quadrats.

40 ÷ 10 = 4

That is 4 urchins per m².

These are not your numbers. Use your own totals.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 2 AND 3

Use your averages

QUESTION 2

B ÷ A

How many times as many?

Take the urchin average for Island B. Divide it by the urchin average for Island A.

Show the division.

QUESTION 3

× 100

Scale it up

A patch of reef is 10 m × 10 m. That is 100 m².

Multiply each urchin average by 100. Do it for both islands.

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Count a sample

A reef is too big to count every urchin. Scientists count a sample: a few small pieces that stand for the whole place.

A scuba diver on the seafloor counting inside a square frame called a quadrat

Photo: Olivier Dugornay, Ifremer, CC BY 4.0

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Quadrats on a transect

A transect is a straight line across the reef. Divers drop the quadrat at set stops along it. They do not pick the spots.

The lab screen for Island A, quadrat 1: a map of the transect with ten numbered stops on the left and the quadrat on the right

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 1

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

No two squares match

Urchins are not spread out evenly. One square alone can fool you. More squares give an average you can trust more.

Purple sea urchins bunched together in one corner of a rocky tide pool

Photo: James St. John, CC BY 2.0

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Reading the clues

You never saw an otter in a quadrat. A hungry predator leaves fewer of the animals it eats.

A sea otter holding a purple sea urchin in its paws

Photo: matt knoth, CC BY 2.0

PART 1 · QUESTION 4

Why count ten?

QUESTION 4

10, not 1

Use the word sample

Look down one column of your Question 1 table. Find a quadrat far from the average.

Why does a dive team count 10 quadrats along a transect, not just one?

The Your data box in the lab: a table with rows for quadrats 1 to 10, a total row and an average row, for urchins and kelp on Island A and Island B

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTION 5

Which island has otters?

Claim

Pick one island. Write A or B in the blank.

Evidence

Give two numbers from your table. Say what each number counts.

Reasoning

Explain why those numbers point to otters. Remember what otters eat.

Last, press your answer in Your claim. The lab tells you the real names of both islands. Write them on the last line.

A rocky green island coast with waves, in the Aleutian Islands of Alaska

Both islands are in the Aleutian chain of Alaska. Same cold sea, same depth, same rock.

Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

Two killer whales leaping out of the sea

TAB 2 · QUESTIONS 6 TO 9

Part 2. Keystone coast

Now you run a model of a whole coast for 50 years.

You choose what happens to the otters. Fur hunters. Killer whales. Or otters swimming back in.

Photo: Robert Pittman, NOAA

PART 2 · TAB 2

Predict, then run

1

In On this coast, check the boxes for your run. Uncheck everything else.

2

In Predict first, pick what urchins and kelp will do by year 50.

3

Draw the same arrows on your worksheet. Up, down, or = for the same.

4

Press Run. Or press Skip to the end.

5

Find Your runs. Copy the three numbers at year 50.

The lab's right-hand panel on Tab 2: the On this coast checkboxes, the Predict first buttons and the Run button
The model coast at year 0: otters floating at the surface, tall kelp, and a few urchins on the seafloor

The picture shows the coast. The box in its corner shows the year and the numbers.

A wrong prediction is fine. Make it before you run.

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 2

PART 2 · QUESTION 6

Your four runs

RunRow on your worksheetBoxes to check in the lab
1Otters at the start (nothing else)Sea otters live here at the start
2Otters at the start + killer whalesSea otters live here at the start, and Killer whales start eating otters
3Otters at the start + fur huntersSea otters live here at the start, and Fur hunters kill otters
4No otters at the start + a few swim inA few otters swim in. Uncheck Sea otters live here at the start.

For every run: predict, run, then write otters per km², urchins per m² and kelp % at year 50.

PART 2 · QUESTION 7

Follow the chain

QUESTION 7

Up or down?

Fill the chain

Look at your killer whale run in Question 6.

Write up or down in each box: otters, then urchins, then kelp.

Compare year 50 with the numbers at year 0.

Two killer whales leaping out of the sea

Photo: Robert Pittman, NOAA

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Keystone species

Pull the keystone out of a stone arch and the arch falls. A keystone species has a much bigger effect than its numbers suggest.

A sea otter floating on its back in calm water

Photo: Mike Baird, CC BY 2.0

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Trophic cascade

A change at the top of a food chain that passes down, one level at a time. Your Question 7 chain is a trophic cascade.

Two killer whales leaping out of the sea

Photo: Robert Pittman, NOAA

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Skipping a level

A predator can change a living thing it never eats. It works through the animal in the middle of the chain.

Tall kelp plants seen from below with sunlight coming through

Photo: NOAA Photo Library, Channel Islands

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

A barren holds on

Urchins can live for years on very little food. They eat young kelp as it starts. Kelp waits until the urchins are brought down.

Many sea urchins on bare rock with almost no kelp left

Photo: Shaun Lee, CC BY 4.0

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 8 AND 9

Explain what you saw

QUESTION 8

Keystone species

Pick two numbers from your table. Use one run with otters and one run without them.

Use them to show that the sea otter is a keystone species.

QUESTION 9

Is the kelp back?

Look at your fur hunter run at year 50.

Compare the otter number with the kelp %. Use them to explain how fast a lost kelp forest comes back.

A large group of southern sea otters floating together in blue water on the California coast

TAB 3 · QUESTIONS 10 TO 14

Part 3. California comeback

In 1938 about 50 sea otters were left in California.

Scientists have counted them every spring since 1982. You will test what holds them back today.

Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Pacific Southwest Region

PART 3 · QUESTION 10

Read the graph

Black dots: the real count each spring.


Red dashed line: the carrying capacity. It is the most otters this coast could hold.


Gold dashed line: the recovery goal.

For question 10

Find four counts: 1938, 1985, the highest year, and 2019.

Tip: press Run and watch the box on the map. It shows the real count for each year.

The lab's graph of California sea otters from 1938 to 2040: black dots for real counts, a red dashed line for carrying capacity and a gold dashed line for the recovery goal
The lab's map of the California coast in 1938, with a box showing the year and the number of otters

The map shows where the otters live. The yellow band grows as the model runs.

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 3 · Counts: U.S. Geological Survey

PART 3 · QUESTION 11

Make the model fit the dots

1

Keep the growth rate at 10%.

2

Leave Range can spread unchecked.

3

Check the boxes for your row: none, disease, shark bites, or both.

4

Press Skip to the end.

5

In Your runs, copy 2019, 2040 and Average miss.

6

Last row: try settings of your own.

The lab's Settings box on Tab 3: growth rate buttons with 10% picked, three checkboxes for shark bites, disease and range, and the Run and Skip to the end buttons
A great white shark swimming among smaller fish

Average miss is how far the model is from the real dots. Smaller is a better fit.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 3 · Photo: Terry Goss, CC BY 2.5

PART 3 · QUESTION 12

Which settings fit best?

QUESTION 12

Best fit

Smallest miss wins

Find the row in your table with the smallest Average miss.

Name its settings. Give the number as your proof.

The lab's graph of California sea otters from 1938 to 2040: black dots for real counts, a red dashed line for carrying capacity and a gold dashed line for the recovery goal

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 3

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Carrying capacity

The largest population a place can hold for a long time. Food, space and shelter set it. Here it is the red dashed line.

The lab's graph of California sea otters from 1938 to 2040: black dots for real counts, a red dashed line for carrying capacity and a gold dashed line for the recovery goal

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 3

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Births and deaths

A population grows when births are more than deaths. It levels off when births and deaths are equal.

A large group of southern sea otters floating together in blue water on the California coast

Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Pacific Southwest Region

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Extra deaths

Predators and disease kill some animals every year, even with plenty of food. Then a population can level off below its carrying capacity.

A great white shark swimming among smaller fish

Photo: Terry Goss, CC BY 2.5

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

A question you can test

Name one thing you change or compare, and one thing you measure. "Are sharks bad?" has nothing to measure.

The lab's Your question box on Tab 3, with drop-down menus to pick a factor and something to measure, and a Put it together button

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 3

PART 3 · QUESTIONS 13 AND 14

What holds the otters back?

QUESTION 13

6,500

The carrying capacity

Where does your best model level off? Write that number. Then use births and deaths to explain the cause and its effect.

QUESTION 14

3,090

The recovery goal

Does your best fit reach the goal and stay there by 2040? What would have to change?

WRAP IT UP · QUESTIONS 15 AND 16

Ask a question. Argue with numbers.

The lab's Your question box on Tab 3, with drop-down menus to pick a factor and something to measure, and a Put it together button

QUESTION 15

Build a question you could test

In Your question, pick a factor. Pick something to measure. Press Put it together, then Save my question.

Copy it to your worksheet. Make sure it is a testable question.

QUESTION 16

"The coast is full." Is it?

Agree or disagree with the classmate. Use at least two numbers from Part 3 as your evidence.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/otters, Tab 3

WRAP IT UP · BACK TO THE START

Revisiting the Phenomenon

How can losing one animal change a whole ecosystem?

1Look again at Photo A and Photo B. Which is a kelp forest and which is an urchin barren? Use your Part 1 averages to explain how you can tell.

2Sea otters never eat kelp. Use the food chain (otters, urchins, kelp) to explain how losing otters can turn a kelp forest into an urchin barren.

3Why is the sea otter called a keystone species? Give two numbers from your Part 2 table as evidence.

4When otters come back, does the kelp come back right away? Use your fur-hunter run from Part 2 as evidence.

A sea otter in the water holding a purple sea urchin

LAST CHECK

Before you hand it in

Name, date and period are on top.

All three tables are full.

Every math answer shows the work.

Every claim uses numbers from your own tables.

Photo: matt knoth, CC BY 2.0