A herd of reindeer grazing on a wide yellow tundra plain in Alaska, with bare mountains behind

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE · CHAPTER 5

Population Limits Lab

Follow along with your worksheet, one question at a time.

mrsajdak.com/populations

Photo: NOAA Central Library

START HERE

Phenomenon: The Reindeer of St. Matthew Island

An old black and white photo of a band of about forty reindeer with antlers standing close together at the foot of a bare, treeless hillside

Photo A. St. Matthew Island, Alaska, 1957.

A colour photo of brown treeless tundra sloping down to a grey sea, with patches of snow on low hills. No animals are in sight.

Photo B. The same island, 2024.

Photos: David R. Klein, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 1957 · Laura McDuffie, U.S. Geological Survey, 2024

START HERE

Observe, wonder, predict

These photographs show the same island in the Bering Sea, 67 years apart. In 1944, people let 29 reindeer loose here. The island had plenty of food and no wolves. In Photo A, the herd is doing well. Today, no reindeer live on the island. What happened to them?

OBSERVEWhat differences do you notice between the photographs?

WONDERWhy might a herd with plenty of food and no wolves disappear?

PREDICTWill a herd keep growing year after year if nothing hunts it? Explain your reasoning.

DRIVING QUESTION

Why can't a population keep growing forever?

START HERE

What Happened Here?

Finished observing? Click here to find out.

St. Matthew Island is far out in the Bering Sea, off the coast of Alaska. In 1944, the U.S. Coast Guard let 29 reindeer loose there. By 1963, there were about 6,000 reindeer on the island. Three years later, in 1966, a biologist named David Klein could find only 42.

Today, you will investigate how fast a population can grow, what slows it down, and what can make it crash. You will grow duckweed on a pond, run the St. Matthew herd year by year, test trout in tanks, and follow newborn bears, robins and perch. At the end of the investigation, you will use your own numbers to explain what happened to the reindeer and return to the original driving question.

BEFORE YOU START

Nothing grows forever

A small forest pond covered edge to edge with bright green duckweed

Fast at first

One plant makes two. Two make four. A pond can turn green in a few weeks.

An old black and white photo of a long line of reindeer crossing flat snowy ground on St. Paul Island

Then it stops

A herd grows fast too. But an island has only so much food.

The four cases

1. Duckweed on a pond

2. Reindeer on an island

3. Trout in tanks

4. Bears, robins and perch

A limiting factor is anything that keeps a population from growing bigger.

Every population can grow fast. So what holds each one back?

Photos: Paavo01, CC BY 4.0 · U.S. National Archives

BEFORE YOU START

What you will learn

DAY 1

I can use a pond model's numbers to tell exponential (J-curve) growth from logistic (S-curve) growth.

I can use the St. Matthew Island reindeer numbers to explain overshoot and a population crash.

DAY 2

I can use survival numbers to find a range of tolerance and say why too much or too little limits.

I can match survivorship curves to r- and K-selected species and say which is most at risk.

BEFORE YOU START

Get set up

1

Open mrsajdak.com/populations on your device.

2

Write your name, the date and your period on the worksheet.

3

Find the four tabs at the top of the lab. Each tab goes with one part of the worksheet.

4

Start on Tab 1. Do not skip ahead.

The top of the lab page, showing the title and four tabs: Duckweed pond, Reindeer island, Trout tanks, Life strategies
Tab in the labWorksheetQuestions
1. Duckweed pondPart 11 to 4
2. Reindeer islandPart 25 to 9
3. Trout tanksPart 310 to 13
4. Life strategiesPart 4 and Wrap it up14 to 16

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations

A flooded forest where the water is covered with a solid green carpet of duckweed around the tree trunks

TAB 1 · QUESTIONS 1 TO 4

Part 1. Duckweed pond

Duckweed is a tiny floating plant. Each plant splits into a new one about every 2 days.

You will grow it on a pond four ways. Find out what stops it.

Photo: U.S. Geological Survey

PART 1 · TAB 1

Set the pond, then run it

1

Find the Settings box. Pick a Pond size. Pick the Nutrients in the water.

2

Check or uncheck Limits on.

3

Press Skip to the end. Or press Run to watch all 30 days.

4

Find Your runs. It keeps the numbers for every setting you try.

The Settings box in the lab: buttons for pond size and nutrients, check boxes for Limits on and Early frost on day 18, then Run, Skip to the end and Speed
A small round pond in the lab on day 14, partly covered with green dots of duckweed

Each dot on the pond stands for 5 plants.

The box in the corner shows the day, the plants and the density.

Change a setting and the run starts over.

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTION 1

Your four runs

RunLimitsPond sizeNutrients
1OFF200 m²Normal
2on200 m²Normal
3on400 m²Normal
4on200 m²Fertilizer runoff
The Your runs box in the lab: one row showing the settings, the plants on day 10 and the plants on day 30

Copy Day 10 and Day 30 for each run.

J or S? Look at the line on the graph. A J-curve keeps shooting up. An S-curve climbs, then levels off.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTION 2

Where does it level off?

1

Run limits on, 200 m², Normal again. Look at the graph.

2

Find the dotted red line. The plants level off near it. Read its number on the left side.

3

The graph names the dotted line. That name is the second blank.

4

For population density, divide the plants on day 30 by the size of the pond.

The lab graph of duckweed plants over 30 days: the line climbs slowly, then fast, then flattens under a dotted red line

Example

1,000 ÷ 50 = 20

A pond with 1,000 plants on 50 m² has 20 plants per m². Not your numbers.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 1

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

J-curve and S-curve

With no limits, more plants make even more: a J, exponential growth. Real limits slow it until it levels off: an S, logistic growth.

The lab graph of duckweed plants over 30 days: the line climbs slowly, then fast, then flattens under a dotted red line

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 1

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Carrying capacity

The level where an S-curve stops. It is the largest population a place can support over time. In the lab it is the dotted red line.

A small forest pond covered edge to edge with bright green duckweed

Photo: Paavo01, CC BY 4.0

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Limiting factors

Food, water, space, light and nutrients can all limit a population. Give it more of what limits it, and the carrying capacity goes up.

The Settings box in the lab: buttons for pond size and nutrients, check boxes for Limits on and Early frost on day 18, then Run, Skip to the end and Speed

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 1

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Two kinds of limits

Density-dependent: hits harder in a crowd, like running out of food, or disease. Density-independent: same share, crowded or not, like a flood.

A flooded forest where the water is covered with a solid green carpet of duckweed around the tree trunks

Photo: U.S. Geological Survey

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 3 AND 4

What held the duckweed back?

QUESTION 3

2

Two limiting factors

A bigger pond raised the carrying capacity. So did fertilizer runoff.

What did each one give the plants more of? Name both limiting factors.

QUESTION 4

6 in 10

An early frost

Check Early frost on day 18. Run it. Watch the line on day 18.

Frost kills 6 of every 10 plants, crowded or not. Is it density-dependent or density-independent? How do you know?

Brown treeless tundra sloping down to a grey sea, with snow patches on low hills, on St. Matthew Island

TAB 2 · QUESTIONS 5 TO 9

Part 2. Reindeer island

This is St. Matthew Island, Alaska. In 1944 the Coast Guard let 29 reindeer loose here.

The island had thick lichen to eat and no wolves. Watch what the herd did next.

Photo: Laura McDuffie, U.S. Geological Survey

PART 2 · QUESTION 5

Run the island. Stop at three years.

1

Go to Tab 2. Keep the island on St. Matthew, 1944.

2

Press Run. Watch the box in the corner. It shows the year and the reindeer.

3

Press Pause when the year is 1957. Write the reindeer in the Model row.

4

Press Keep going. Pause again at 1963 and at 1966.

5

Missed a year? Let it finish. Then press Run again.

The Settings box in the lab: buttons for St. Matthew, 1944 and St. Paul, 1911, check boxes for Wolves on the island and The hard winter of 1963 to 1964, then Run, Skip to the end and Speed
St. Matthew Island in the lab in 1950: a long pale island with a few dark dots for reindeer, and a box showing the year, reindeer, density and lichen left

Each dot stands for 10 reindeer.

The black dots on the graph are the real counts.

Keep Speed on Normal. Fast is hard to pause.

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 2

PART 2 · QUESTION 6

How far past the limit?

1

Find Your runs. Read the number under Highest (year). That is the highest count.

2

Divide it by 128 square miles. That is the density.

3

Look under the graph. The orange dotted line is the carrying capacity. Read its number.

4

Divide the highest count by the carrying capacity.

The lab graph for St. Paul Island: the reindeer line climbs to a peak and crashes, the green lichen line falls, and an orange dotted line near the bottom marks the carrying capacity

This graph is the other island, St. Paul. Yours will look different.

Example

3,000 ÷ 200 = 15

A herd of 3,000 on land that can feed 200 is 15 times too big. Not your numbers.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 2

PART 2 · QUESTION 7

Three more numbers

QUESTION 7

Lichen

The food

Run St. Matthew again. Pause at 1963.

Write the Lichen left from the corner box.

QUESTION 7

Winter

Take the winter away

Uncheck The hard winter of 1963 to 1964. Run it. Pause at 1966.

Write the reindeer in 1966.

QUESTION 7

Wolves

Add a predator

Check the hard winter again. Check Wolves on the island. Run it to the end.

Write the highest count, J or S, and the lichen left in 1990.

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

What the island can feed

Lichen grows back very slowly. The carrying capacity is the most reindeer the lichen can feed year after year: the orange dotted line.

Brown treeless tundra sloping down to a grey sea, with snow patches on low hills, on St. Matthew Island

Photo: Laura McDuffie, U.S. Geological Survey

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Overshoot, then crash

A herd can eat a stored food supply faster than it grows back. It grows past the carrying capacity: overshoot. When the food is gone, it crashes.

The lab graph for St. Paul Island: the reindeer line climbs to a peak and crashes, the green lichen line falls, and an orange dotted line near the bottom marks the carrying capacity

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 2

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Trigger or cause?

A hard winter is density-independent. Food is density-dependent. Take one factor away and see if the crash still happens.

An old black and white photo of a long line of reindeer crossing flat snowy ground on St. Paul Island

Photo: U.S. National Archives

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Predators

Predators are density-dependent. When prey are crowded, predators catch more. This can hold a population steady, below the carrying capacity.

The Settings box in the lab: buttons for St. Matthew, 1944 and St. Paul, 1911, check boxes for Wolves on the island and The hard winter of 1963 to 1964, then Run, Skip to the end and Speed

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 2

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 8 AND 9

Find the real limit

QUESTION 8

Past the limit

Use the words carrying capacity and overshoot.

Why could the herd grow so far past what the island could feed? Use your lichen number from Question 7.

QUESTION 9a

Winter or food?

Use your no-winter number from Question 7.

Was the real limit the winter or the food? Use density-dependent or density-independent.

QUESTION 9b

Why did the lichen last?

Look at your wolves run.

Why did the lichen not run out this time? Compare the reindeer line with the orange line.

A brook trout with pale spots and red fins swimming over round stones in a dark stream

TAB 3 · QUESTIONS 10 TO 13

Part 3. Trout tanks

The brook trout is New York’s state fish.

pH tells how acid water is. Low pH is acid. You will test 13 tanks. Only the pH is different.

Photo: Eric Engbretson, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

PART 3 · QUESTION 10

Run the tanks for 30 days

1

Go to Tab 3. There are 13 tanks. Each one starts with 20 trout.

2

Press Run. Or press Skip to the end.

3

Wait for Day 30 of 30 in the corner box.

4

Read the number above each tank. Or use the table in Your runs.

5

Write how many are alive under each pH.

Thirteen fish tanks in the lab on day 8, in two rows, each labelled with its pH and how many trout are alive

This picture is day 8, not day 30. Gray fish at the top have died.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 3

PART 3 · QUESTION 11

The range of tolerance

Optimum range

The pH where the trout do best.

Zone of stress

Some trout live. Some die. The pH is a little too low or too high.

No survivors

The pH is much too low or too high. No trout live.

Check Show the zones on the graph. Read the pH numbers under each zone. Fill in the blanks.

The Settings box in the lab for the trout tanks, with a check box that says Show the zones on the graph The lab bar graph of trout alive in each tank on day 8, one bar for each pH from 4.0 to 10.0

The zones show up as color bands behind the bars.

Screenshots: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 3

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Range of tolerance

Every living thing survives only in a range of conditions, like temperature or pH. Too little can limit a population. So can too much.

A brook trout with pale spots and red fins swimming over round stones in a dark stream

Photo: Eric Engbretson, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Three zones

Optimum range: they do best. Zone of stress: some survive but grow poorly. Zone of intolerance: none survive.

The lab bar graph of trout alive in each tank on day 8: the middle tanks are full, and the bars get shorter toward the low and high pH ends

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 3

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

pH and acid rain

pH 7 is neutral. Lower is more acidic, and each step is 10 times more. Gases from burning coal and oil mix with rain and make acid rain.

A long narrow mountain lake between a steep rock cliff and a forested slope in the Adirondacks, with clouds reflected in the water

Photo: G. Edward Johnson, CC BY 4.0

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

A fair test

To show a cause, change only one thing. Keep everything else the same. This is a controlled experiment.

Thirteen fish tanks in the lab, in two rows, each labelled with its pH and how many trout are alive

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 3

PART 3 · QUESTIONS 12 AND 13

One cause, and a real lake

A long narrow mountain lake between a steep rock cliff and a forested slope in the Adirondacks, with clouds reflected in the water

QUESTION 12

Why is this good evidence?

Read the note under the tanks. List what was the same in every tank.

How many things were different? Why does that matter?

QUESTION 13

Acid rain in the Adirondacks

Acid rain has pushed some Adirondack lakes down to about pH 4.8.

Use the range of tolerance and the two tanks closest to 4.8 to predict what happens to the trout.

Photo: G. Edward Johnson, CC BY 4.0

A black bear mother standing in tall grass between her two cubs, one black and one cinnamon brown

TAB 4 · QUESTIONS 14 AND 15

Part 4. Life strategies

Some animals have a few young and take care of them. Some have thousands and leave.

You will follow 1,000 newborns of three species. Then you will see which one bounces back fastest.

Photo: Neal Herbert, National Park Service

PART 4 · TAB 4

Three ways to raise young

A black bear mother standing in a grassy field with two small cubs beside her

Black bears

2 or 3 cubs, every other year. Cubs stay with mom about 17 months.

An American robin on a lawn pulling a worm out of the grass

American robins

6 to 12 eggs a year. Chicks are fed for about a month.

A yellow perch with dark stripes down its gold side, against a black background

Yellow perch

10,000 to 40,000 eggs a year. No care from parents.

r-selected: many young, little care. K-selected: few young, lots of care. Which is which?

Photos: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

PART 4 · QUESTION 14

Follow 1,000 newborns

1

Go to Tab 4. Under What to watch, pick Survivorship. Press Skip to the end.

2

In Your runs, copy Alive at 10% and at 50% for each species.

3

Pick Recovery. Press Skip to the end. Copy the years to get back to 90%.

4

Leave Curve type and r or K empty for now.

Three boxes of 1,000 dots in the lab, one each for black bears, American robins and yellow perch, part way through a survivorship run; coloured dots are alive and gray dots have died

Coloured dots are alive. Gray dots have died.

Look at the shape of each line on the Survivorship graph. You will name it after the Learn It slides.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 4

PART 4 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Survivorship curves

Late loss: most live to old age. Constant loss: the same share die at every age. Early loss: most die very young.

Three boxes of 1,000 dots in the lab part way through a run: nearly all the black bears are alive, a scattering of robins are left, and only 2 perch are alive

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 4

PART 4 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Reading the graph

The graph uses a log scale. Each gridline is 10 times the one below it. A straight line sloping down means the same share die at every age.

An American robin on a lawn pulling a worm out of the grass

Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

PART 4 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

r-selected

Many young, little or no care. Most young die. The rest grow up fast and breed early. After a bad year, the population grows back quickly.

A yellow perch with dark stripes down its gold side, against a black background

Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

PART 4 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

K-selected

Few young, lots of care. More young survive, but they grow up slowly. (K stands for carrying capacity.) After a big loss, the population comes back slowly.

A black bear mother standing in a grassy field with two small cubs beside her

Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service

PART 4 · QUESTIONS 14 AND 15

Who is most at risk?

Finish Q14

Name each curve type: late, constant or early loss. Mark each species r or K.

The question

A disease kills most of the animals in all three populations in one year. Which species is most likely to go extinct? Use r-selected or K-selected.

Your numbers

Look at the recovery column in your Question 14 table. Compare the slowest species with the fastest.

One life fact

Find a fact in the Life facts box that explains why that species is so slow to come back.

The Life facts box in the lab: a table for black bears, American robins and yellow perch with rows for young per year, first breeds at, care from parents and longest life

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/populations, Tab 4

WRAP IT UP · QUESTION 16

Can any population grow forever?

The claim

“No population can grow forever.”

Evidence 1

Pick one tab. Give a number that shows the population stopped growing, or crashed.

Evidence 2

Pick a different tab. Give a number from that one too.

Reasoning

What do the limits have in common? Think about what every habitat has only so much of.

A long line of caribou walking across flat white snow under a grey sky

A caribou herd in Alaska. Caribou and reindeer are the same species.

Photo: U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Alaska

WRAP IT UP · BACK TO THE START

Revisiting the Phenomenon

Why can't a population keep growing forever?

1Using evidence from today's investigation, explain how 29 reindeer became about 6,000 in 19 years.

2Why did the herd crash? Use the words carrying capacity and overshoot.

3What was the real limiting factor on the island: the hard winter or the food? What evidence from Tab 2 supports your answer?

4The duckweed leveled off, but the reindeer crashed. Why did the two populations end so differently?

A bare green and brown island with cliffs dropping to the sea, and a second island faint in the mist behind it

LAST CHECK

Before you hand it in

Name, date and period are on top.

All four tables are full.

Questions 2, 6, 7 and 11 have every blank filled in.

Question 16 uses numbers from two different tabs.

Photo: Anne Morkill, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service