Coral reefs need warm water, but water that is too warm can kill them. Count the living coral on seven real reefs in the middle of the Pacific, the way National Geographic Explorer Enric Sala's team did. Then find out what really decides which reefs survive a heat wave.
Finish these steps in the lab. Then this box opens.
Divers lay a measuring tape 25 meters long on the reef floor. That line is a transect. They swim along it and count every fish in a strip beside it. Every survey uses the same kind of line, so another team can repeat it and check it.
Along the tape, the divers photograph the floor. Each photo is a photo quadrat. Points are dropped on the photo, and someone counts the points that land on living coral. Coral cover is the percent of the floor that is living coral. Your photos had 25 points. 100 ÷ 25 = 4, so each point is worth 4%. The real team used 100 points on each photo and 10 photos on each tape.
Satellites measure the temperature of the ocean's surface every day. When the water gets hotter than its usual warmest month, they add up the extra heat, week by week. That total is heat weeks. 1 heat week is like 1 week of water about 2°F (1°C) too hot. At about 4 heat weeks, corals start to bleach. At about 8, many corals can die.
If heat alone decided how much coral lives on a reef, the hottest reefs would have the least coral. Look at your graph. They do not. A, D and G are the hottest reefs, and they have some of the most coral. So something else must be different about the reefs with little coral. Look at their cards.
Now answer Q3 to Q5 on your worksheet.
Finish these steps in the lab. Then this box opens.
Enric Sala is a marine ecologist and a National Geographic Explorer. He spent years watching reefs die. So he asked a new question: what does a reef look like with no people at all? In 2005 he led a team of divers to these islands in the middle of the Pacific Ocean. Your seven cards are their reefs. Later he started Pristine Seas, a project that helps countries protect the wildest places left in the ocean.
A fair test changes only one thing. C and E are different in heat and in fishing. If E has less coral, you cannot tell which one caused it. C and A are both unfished. Only the heat is different. That is a fair test of heat. A gets more than 5 times the heat weeks of C, and both reefs have 44% coral.
A coral is an animal. Tiny algae live inside it and make food for it from sunlight. When the water stays too hot, the algae leave. The coral turns white. That is coral bleaching. If the heat lasts too long, the coral starves and can die.
Heat waves hit these islands in 1997 and 2002, on fished and unfished reefs. Where people fish, at B and E, much of the coral died and did not come back. At Kingman (C), with no people, the coral stayed about the same.
Resilience is the ability of an ecosystem to bounce back after a disturbance, like a heat wave. On unfished reefs, plant-eating fish graze on seaweed. That keeps bare spots open, so baby corals can settle and grow. Fishing takes those fish away, and seaweed covers the dead coral instead.
At Kingman, sharks and other top predators made up 85% of the weight of all the fish. At Kiritimati, where 5,100 people fish, it was 19%. Kingman had about 4 times as much fish in all.
Palmyra (F) has no fishing but only 20% coral. Its strip says a Navy base dug up part of the reef in the 1940s. When one point does not fit the pattern, scientists look for another cause.
Now answer Q9 to Q11 on your worksheet.
Finish these steps in the lab. Then this box opens.
Some corals add a layer of skeleton every year, a bit like tree rings. A bleaching heat wave leaves an extra thick, heavy layer called a stress band. Scientists drill a long, thin core out of the coral. They scan it with a CT scanner, the same kind a hospital uses. Then they count the layers back, year by year.
The cores show 10 bleaching heat waves from 1960 to 2016. Every one came in an El Niño year, a natural pattern that warms this part of the Pacific every few years. After each of the earlier ones, the reef bounced back. In 2012, Jarvis was rated one of the healthiest reefs in the world.
Then came the biggest heat in the record. By November 2015, almost all of the coral had bleached. By May 2016, about 95% of the corals were dead. A few corals that looked dead grew new tissue by 2017.
Weather is what the air and water are doing now, this day or this season. Climate is the usual pattern over a long time, about 30 years. One hot summer is weather. It cannot tell you if the climate has changed. Only the long record let scientists say that 2015 to 2016 was bigger than any heat wave in 56 years.
Sala's team compared many reefs: many places. The Jarvis cores cover many years. That is how scientists tell what a changing climate does to an ecosystem, and not just what one bad year did.
Now answer Q14 to Q16 on your worksheet.
Printable student worksheet (PDF) · two pages, goes with this lab
Low-write worksheet (PDF) · same questions with tick boxes, word banks and worked examples
Teacher guide: NYSSLS, SEP and CCC alignment (PDF)
What you will learn. I can use real reef data to find a pattern and pick a fair comparison. I can explain how a scientist like Enric Sala studies a warming ocean. I can plan a measurement to test how climate affects a local ecosystem.
Tabs 1 and 2 use real numbers from Sandin, Smith, Sala and others (2008), "Baselines and degradation of coral reefs in the Northern Line Islands," PLoS ONE 3(2): e1548, Table 1. Heat weeks are the average yearly peak of degree heating weeks; Jarvis, Howland and Baker are NOAA surveys in that table. The photo quadrats are drawings, not photos: each one holds exactly the number of coral points that matches the reef's measured coral cover, rounded to the nearest 4% (real values 43.9, 19.5, 43.8, 55.6, 15.0, 20.4 and 49.5%). Tab 3 uses Barkley, Cohen and others (2018), "Repeat bleaching of a central Pacific coral reef over the past six decades (1960–2016)," Communications Biology 1: 177. The CT scan is a drawing of their record; three events the paper gives as 40 to 50% are drawn at 45%. Environmental Science, Chapter 6, Explorers at Work: Saving the Last Wild Places in the Ocean (pp. 158–159).
© 2026 Ryan Sajdak. This lab, its worksheets and its slides are free to use, share and change under the Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license: give credit, do not sell it, and share your version the same way.