A torrential rain falling on a Buffalo street, water running in the road

ENVIRONMENTAL SCIENCE · WATER QUALITY

Combined Sewer Overflow Lab

Follow along with your worksheet, one question at a time.

mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0

START HERE

Phenomenon: Same water, the next day

A sunny beach on the Buffalo waterfront with a dog in the water and grain elevators behind

Photo A. Gallagher Beach, Buffalo, on a clear day.

A warning sign nailed to a post on a wooded riverbank path, telling people to avoid contact with the water

Photo B. A warning on a riverbank path after a sewage spill.

Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Photo: G. Edward Johnson, CC BY 4.0

START HERE

Observe, wonder, predict

On a clear day, people swim and play in the water. After a big rainstorm, signs go up telling people to stay out of it. Rain is just water. How could rain make a river or a lake unsafe?

OBSERVEWhat is different about the water in the two photos?

WONDERWhat could rain carry into a river?

PREDICTWhich storm would be worse for a river: a short, hard thunderstorm or a gentle rain that lasts all day? Why?

A storm drain grate in a curb with the words Dump no waste, drains to waterways

A storm drain in Massachusetts. Some drains have a sign like this one.

Photo: Daderot, CC0

DRIVING QUESTION

Why does a hard rain in Buffalo send sewage into the river, and what can a city do about it?

START HERE

What happened here?

Finished observing? Click here to find out.

In many older cities, Buffalo among them, one set of pipes carries sewage from homes and rain from the streets. In a big storm those pipes get more water than the treatment plant can take. The extra, rain and raw sewage together, spills into the river through a pipe called an outfall. It is called a combined sewer overflow, or CSO. The bacteria in the sewage are why the signs go up.

Today you will run a model of a city, its sewer and its river. You will follow the water through one storm, try four storms, test three ways to fix the sewer, and see what reaches the river. At the end you will come back to the driving question.

START HERE

What an overflow looks like

A wide brown river under a grey sky with an industrial shoreline, where a combined sewer is discharging

Washington, D.C.

A combined sewer pouring into the Anacostia River in 2018.

A huge round iron flap gate at the end of a concrete tunnel, stained by water, on the edge of a river

London

A CSO outfall on the River Thames. When the sewer is full, this gate swings open and the overflow pours out.

An aerial photo of a city harbor where a dark plume of river water spreads into a lake

Buffalo, 1973

Polluted water from the Buffalo River spreading into Lake Erie, photographed for the EPA.

Photo: Antony-22, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Photo: Z22, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Photo: George Burns, EPA Documerica, National Archives, public domain

BEFORE YOU START

Six words you will need

Combined sewer

One pipe that carries sewage from homes and stormwater from the streets.

Interceptor

The pipe to the treatment plant. It can only carry so much.

Regulator

The chamber where the flow splits: to the plant, to the tank, or over the wall.

Storage tank

Holds extra water during a storm, then sends it to the plant later.

Outfall

The end of the pipe where an overflow leaves for the river.

m³ and m³/s

A cubic meter is 1,000 liters. m³/s is how many pass each second.

The lab's drawing of a city, its sewer and a river, cut open from the side on a dry day

Find each part in the lab drawing: the sewer pipe, the regulator, the tank, the outfall and the pipe to the plant.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

BEFORE YOU START

What you will learn

I can use a model to explain how a pipe that carries both sewage and rain ends up spilling into a river.

I can use numbers from a simulation to compare ways to cut sewer overflows and defend the best one.

BEFORE YOU START

Get set up

1

Open mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow on your device.

2

Write your name, the date and your period on the worksheet.

3

Get a calculator.

4

Find the drawing at the top, the sliders on the left and the results on the right.

5

Play storm runs one day. The time slider moves to any minute.

The lab time bar: Play storm and Reset clock buttons, a time slider, and the hour
WorksheetWhat you changeQuestions
Part 1Only the clock1 to 4
Part 2The storm and the paving5 to 7
Part 3Tank, green, interceptor8 to 10
Part 4River flow11 to 13
Wrap it upNothing: you decide14

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

Cars splashing through deep floodwater on a city street in Buffalo

QUESTIONS 1 TO 4

Part 1. One pipe, two jobs

Leave every slider where it starts. You will only move the clock.

Watch where the water from homes and streets goes at four times of day.

Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 1 · QUESTION 1

Read the lab at four times of day

1

Drag the time slider to hour 0.5.

2

Is it raining? Read Homes and Storm drains in the top right corner.

3

Read the flow on the pipe to the treatment plant, at the bottom.

4

Read the storage tank.

5

Do the same at hours 2.5, 6.0 and 12.0. Combined flow = homes + storm drains.

The lab's drawing of a city, its sewer and a river, cut open from the side during the storm, with rain falling and the storage tank filling

Hour 1.7 of the starting storm: rain is falling and the tank is filling.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 2 AND 3

Two sources, one pipe

The lab's drawing of a city, its sewer and a river, cut open from the side at hour 2.2: the tank is full, water spills out of the outfall into the river, and the swimming sign says closed

Hour 2.2. Watch the box labeled Regulator, and the outfall.

QUESTION 2

Streets against homes

At hour 2.5, divide storm drains by homes. How many times bigger?

QUESTION 3

Where does the rest go?

Only 0.21 m³/s goes to the plant. Press Play storm and watch the regulator. Describe where the rest of the water goes, in order.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

One pipe, two jobs

Older parts of Buffalo have combined sewers: one pipe for sewage from homes and stormwater from the streets. Newer places use two separate pipes.

An aerial photo of downtown Buffalo and its harbor

Photo: Carol M. Highsmith, Library of Congress, public domain

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

The plant has a limit

The interceptor carries water to the treatment plant, but only so much. In the lab it takes 0.21 m³/s: three times a normal day's sewage.

Two huge shiny silver egg-shaped tanks joined by a walkway at a sewage treatment plant, against a blue sky

Photo: Steven Olswang, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Extra water waits, then spills

Extra flow fills a storage tank. When the tank is full, the water climbs over a low wall called a weir and leaves through the outfall.

The lab's drawing of a city, its sewer and a river, cut open from the side with the tank full and water spilling out the outfall

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

That spill is a CSO

A combined sewer overflow is rain and raw sewage pouring into a river with no treatment. Sewage carries bacteria, so beaches downstream close.

A huge round iron flap gate at the end of a concrete tunnel on the edge of a river

Photo: Z22, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 1 · QUESTION 4

After the storm

The lab's drawing of a city, its sewer and a river, cut open from the side at hour 6: no rain, the storage tank partly full and draining back toward the plant

Hour 6. No rain, but look at the tank and the pipe to the plant.

QUESTION 4

0.05 → 0.21

More out than in

Homes send about 0.05 m³/s, but the plant gets 0.21. Where does the extra come from?

Why does that make the tank useful for the next storm?

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

Dark, heavy storm clouds over a tree-lined avenue in Buffalo

QUESTIONS 5 TO 7

Part 2. Storms and streets

Not every storm is the same. Some are short and violent. Some are gentle and never stop.

Which one is worse for the river?

Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 2 · QUESTION 5

Try four storms

1

First row: the starting storm, 12 mm/h for 2 h.

2

Press each storm preset: Light drizzle, Thunderstorm, All-day soaker.

3

Copy the intensity and length from the sliders.

4

Total rain = intensity × length.

5

Read the results boxes. They fill in right away.

The three storm preset buttons in the lab: Light drizzle, Thunderstorm, All-day soaker The six results boxes in the lab after a thunderstorm: peak runoff, overflow to the river, overflow duration, wastewater treated, peak river E. coli, swimming closed

The results for the thunderstorm. You do not have to play the storm to read them.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 3

How hard, or how much?

Total rain = intensity × length. 40 mm/h for half an hour is 20 mm. 6 mm/h for 8 hours is 48 mm: more than twice as much water.

The lab flow graph for the all-day soaker: the combined flow stays above the interceptor line for hours

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 3

Limits that do not care how hard it rains

The plant takes 0.21 m³/s and the tank holds 5,000 m³, whatever the storm. Every bit of water above those limits overflows.

The lab's drawing of a city, its sewer and a river, cut open from the side with the tank full and water spilling out the outfall

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 3

Hard surfaces shed water

Roofs, roads and parking lots are impervious: in the lab, 90 out of every 100 drops run off. Lawns and soil soak up most of it: only 15 run off.

Cars splashing through deep floodwater on a city street in Buffalo

Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 6 AND 7

The surprise, and the streets

QUESTION 6

3×

The gentle storm wins

The all-day soaker sends about three times as much overflow as the thunderstorm.

Explain why, using total rain and how long the sewer stays over its limit.

QUESTION 7

10% → 95%

Pave the city

Set the storm back to 12 mm/h for 2 h. Change only Paved and roofed area: 10%, 65%, 95%.

Explain why paving sends more water into the sewer.

An aerial view of an enormous rectangular quarry pit with stepped sides beside a river and highways

QUESTIONS 8 TO 10

Part 3. Fix the sewer

Cities have three ways to stop overflows: store the water, carry more of it, or keep it out of the sewer.

Test all three on two storms.

Photo: Pi.1415926535, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 3

Three ways to fix it, for real

Looking down a deep round concrete shaft to the mouth of a tunnel far below

Store it

London's Thames Tideway Tunnel runs 25 km under the river to catch the city's overflows. In the lab: a bigger storage tank.

Two huge shiny silver egg-shaped tanks at a sewage treatment plant

Treat more of it

A bigger plant and bigger pipes to reach it. In the lab: a bigger interceptor.

A green roof planted with grass and shrubs on top of a large city building, seen from a skyscraper

Keep it out

Plants on Chicago City Hall's roof soak up rain before it reaches a drain. In the lab: green infrastructure.

Photo: Matt Brown, CC BY 2.0 · Photo: Steven Olswang, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Photo: TonyTheTiger, CC BY-SA 3.0

PART 3 · QUESTION 8

One change at a time

1

Paved area back to 65%. Press Thunderstorm.

2

Read Overflow to river. That is the "no upgrade" row.

3

Make one change. Read the overflow. Put that slider back.

4

Tank 10,000 m³. Then green infrastructure 40%. Then interceptor 6×.

5

Do it all again with All-day soaker.

UpgradeSlider to moveChange it to
Bigger tankStorage tank volume10,000 m³
Green infrastructureGreen infrastructure40%
Bigger pipeInterceptor capacity6×
No upgradePut them all back5,000 m³, 0%, 3×

The sliders are in the box Set up the storm and the city, under The city and The sewer system.

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

A tank holds a fixed amount

A tank can only fill once per storm. Doubling it catches exactly 5,000 m³ more, as long as the storm is big enough to fill it.

Inside a huge round concrete shaft, with a work platform hanging on cables above a green floor

Photo: Matt Brown, CC BY 2.0

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Short storms: store the burst

A thunderstorm sends a short, huge burst. A big enough tank can catch most of it before it ever reaches the outfall.

An aerial view of an enormous rectangular quarry pit beside a river and highways

Photo: Pi.1415926535, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Long storms: keep it out

An all-day storm sends more water than any tank holds. Green infrastructure keeps rain out of the sewer the whole time it falls.

A thick rain garden of shrubs and plants against a concrete building, next to a walkway

Photo: DASonnenfeld, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Every fix has a cost

Tanks and tunnels cost billions and take years to dig. Bigger pipes mean torn-up streets. Green infrastructure needs land and care.

A street of red brick paving in front of row houses

Photo: Hullian111, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 3 · QUESTIONS 9 AND 10

Which fix wins?

QUESTION 9

5,000

The same cut twice

Doubling the tank cut both storms' overflow by the same amount.

Why the same amount?

QUESTION 10

?

It depends on the storm

Which upgrade worked best for the thunderstorm? For the soaker?

Explain why the best fix depends on the kind of storm.

An aerial photo of a city harbor where a dark plume of river water spreads into a lake

QUESTIONS 11 TO 13

Part 4. The river

The overflow is over in a couple of hours. The river is not.

Change only how much water the river carries, and watch the beach.

Photo: George Burns, EPA Documerica, National Archives, public domain

PART 4 · QUESTION 11

A small river and a big one

1

Tank, green infrastructure and interceptor back to their starting values.

2

Press Thunderstorm.

3

Change only River flow: 2, 6, then 15 m³/s.

4

Read Peak river E. coli and Swimming closed.

5

A + means still closed at midnight.

The lab graph of E. coli in the river: it jumps from 50 to about 10,000 during the overflow, then falls slowly, crossing the red advisory line near hour 12

The thunderstorm with a river flow of 6 m³/s. The red dashed line is the swim advisory level.

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

PART 4 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Bacteria tell us about sewage

E. coli lives in human and animal guts. Lots of it in a river means sewage is there. Beaches close above 235 per 100 mL.

A warning sign nailed to a post on a wooded riverbank path

Photo: G. Edward Johnson, CC BY 4.0

PART 4 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Dilution

The same sewage mixed into more water makes a weaker mix. A bigger river dilutes the overflow, so the peak is lower.

The Buffalo River on a winter day, wide and calm, with grain elevators along its banks

Photo: Michael Barera, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 4 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Flushing

A river carries polluted water away and brings clean water in. A faster river flushes it out sooner, so the beach reopens sooner.

Looking up the Buffalo River from a park on its bank, with bridges and grain elevators

Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 4 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Slow to clear

The overflow stops, but the bacteria are still in the water. In the lab, the river has to wash the bacteria out over and over before the count drops below 235.

The lab graph of E. coli in the river falling slowly for hours after the overflow ends

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/sewer-overflow

PART 4 · QUESTIONS 12 AND 13

The river remembers

QUESTION 12

2 → 15

Dilution and flushing

The same overflow reached the river all three times.

Use dilution and flushing to explain your table.

QUESTION 13

~2.6 → ~12.6

Closed long after

River flow back to 6. The overflow stops near hour 2.6, but swimming stays closed until about hour 12.6.

Use both graphs to explain why.

WRAP IT UP · QUESTION 14

You run the sewer authority

Your choice

Your city can pay for one upgrade: a bigger tank, more green infrastructure, or a bigger interceptor.

Evidence

Back it with at least two numbers from two different storms.

Reasoning

Explain why those numbers make it the best choice for your city.

The cost

Name one cost or drawback of your choice.

A sidewalk rain garden of shrubs and grasses in a curbside planter on a city street

A curbside rain garden in New York City, built to catch street runoff before it reaches a storm drain.

Photo: ChrisHamby, CC BY-SA 4.0

WRAP IT UP · BACK TO THE START

Revisiting the phenomenon

Why does a hard rain in Buffalo send sewage into the river, and what can a city do about it?

1Rain is just water. Explain how a hard rain sends sewage into the river. Use the words interceptor, storage tank and outfall.

2Look back at your PREDICT answer. Which storm was worse for the river, and what number from the lab shows it?

3Why do beaches stay closed so long after the rain stops?

4Name one thing at your home or school that sends rain to the sewer, and one change that could keep it out.

A rainbow over a Buffalo street corner after a rain, with a water tower

LAST CHECK

Before you hand it in

Name, date and period are on top.

All five tables are full.

Every number has its unit.

Question 14 has a fix, two numbers from two storms, and a cost.

Photo: Andre Carrotflower, CC BY-SA 4.0