The neck of a human thigh bone cut across. A thin pale rim surrounds red bone full of tiny holes, with a yellow patch in the middle

ANATOMY & PHYSIOLOGY · SECTION 7.2

Solid or Spongy?

Bone tissue lab. Follow along with your worksheet, one question at a time.

mrsajdak.com/bonetissue

Photo: Steven Fruitsmaak, public domain

OPTION A · VIDEO

Cut Through a Bone

Clip 1 is a butcher cutting a beef marrow bone on a band saw. Clip 2 is a micro-CT scan, a 3D X-ray, of the inside of a bone. Clip 3 is a short news story about a new way to see bone loss.

Watch for

In Clip 1, look at the cut face. What is in the middle? What is around it?

In Clip 2, look at the inside of the bone. Is it solid?

Is every part of a bone built the same way?

Next: Observe, wonder, predict →

CLIP 0:00 TO 1:05

Open on YouTube

Videos on YouTube: ASM butchers; Micro Photonics; Canadian Light Source.

OPTION B · TRY IT · 4 MINUTES

Sponge or Bone?

1

Put on gloves. Look at the cut end of the class bone. It is full of holes, like a sponge.

2

Press a kitchen sponge with a pencil eraser. Watch it squash.

3

Press the spongy end of the bone the same way. Tap it with the pencil.

4

Put one drop of water on the sponge and one on the bone end. Where does it go?

Next: Observe, wonder, predict →

You need

A clean, dry kitchen sponge

The class bone, split, with a spongy end (cooked and cleaned)

A pencil

A dropper and a cup of water

Gloves

Watch for

The sponge squashes. The bone does not.

The water vanishes into both.

So what do the holes in bone do, if they do not make it soft?

OPTION C · PHOTOS

Phenomenon: One Bone, Two Cuts

A human thigh bone sawn across its shaft. A thick pale ring of solid bone surrounds a dark hollow in the middle

Cut A. A human thigh bone, sawn across.

The neck of a human thigh bone cut across. A thin pale rim surrounds red bone full of tiny holes, with a yellow patch in the middle

Cut B. The same kind of bone, cut in another place.

Photos: MAKY.OREL, Charles University, CC0 · Steven Fruitsmaak, public domain

START HERE

Observe, wonder, predict

Both cuts are through a human thigh bone, the femur. One cut is solid all the way around a hole. The other is full of tiny holes, with only a thin rim.

OBSERVEWhat is different about the two cut faces?

WONDERWhat do you wonder about the holes?

PREDICTWhich part of the bone is stronger? Which is lighter? Explain your reasoning.

A human thigh bone sawn across its shaft. A thick pale ring of solid bone surrounds a dark hollow in the middle

Cut A, up close.

The neck of a human thigh bone cut across. A thin pale rim surrounds red bone full of tiny holes, with a yellow patch in the middle

Cut B, up close.

Photos: MAKY.OREL, Charles University, CC0 · Steven Fruitsmaak, public domain

DRIVING QUESTION

Why is one bone built two ways: solid in the middle, full of holes at the ends?

START HERE

Where Were These Cuts?

Finished observing? Click here to find out.

Cut A goes through the shaft of a femur, the long middle of the thigh bone. It is from a university bone collection. Cut B goes through the neck of a femur, just below the ball that fits into the hip. A surgeon removed it during a hip replacement. The red is marrow and blood.

Watched the video or tried it? Click here.

The butcher cut through a beef leg bone, and the 3D scan looked inside a bone. The kitchen sponge squashed, but the bone end did not, even though both are full of holes.

Today, you will measure the solid wall of a real femur and drop water on it. You will count points on real microscope pictures of bone. Then you will use real data to see which bones break first when bone gets weak. At the end, you will return to the driving question.

BEFORE YOU START

What you will learn

I can compare where compact and spongy bone are and what each one looks like.

I can explain how the structure of each tissue fits its job.

I can use bone data to explain why osteoporosis breaks some bones first.

BEFORE YOU START

Get set up

1

Open mrsajdak.com/bonetissue on your device.

2

Write your name, the date and your period on the worksheet.

3

Find the three tabs at the top of the lab. Each tab goes with one part of the worksheet.

4

Start on Tab 1. Do not skip ahead.

The top of the lab page, showing the title and three tabs: Cut the bone open, Under the microscope, Bone loss over a lifetime
Tab in the labWorksheetQuestions
1. Cut the bone openPart 11 to 7
2. Under the microscopePart 28 to 13
3. Bone loss over a lifetimePart 3 and Explain it14 to 17

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/bonetissue

A human thigh bone sawn across its shaft. A thick pale ring of solid bone surrounds a dark hollow in the middle

TAB 1 · QUESTIONS 1 TO 7

Part 1. Cut the bone open

Two cuts through a human femur.

Measure the solid wall in the middle and near the end. Then drop water on each.

Photo: MAKY.OREL, Charles University, CC0

PART 1 · QUESTION 1

Look before you measure

Inside the end

Look at Cut B, in the middle of the red part.

Center of the shaft

Look at Cut A, in the middle.

Wall of the shaft

Look at Cut A, the pale ring.

For each place, tick one: solid and smooth, full of holes, or empty space.

The lab with two photos: on the left the femur shaft cut across with yellow spots 1 and 2 on its wall, on the right the neck of the femur cut across with spots 3 and 4 on its rim

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/bonetissue, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 2 AND 3

Measure the solid wall

1

Click yellow spot 1. It shows up big in the Zoomed in box.

2

Click where the solid, pale wall starts. Then click where it ends.

3

Press Check my measurement. Write the lab’s number.

4

Do spots 2, 3 and 4.

LIVE LAB · TAB 1

New tab

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 2 AND 3

Average, then compare

QUESTION 2

Average

Add try 1 and try 2.

Divide by 2.

QUESTION 3

How many times as thick?

Shaft average ÷ end average.

Example

A wall is 9.0 mm in the middle and 3.0 mm near the end.

9.0 ÷ 3.0 = 3

These are not your numbers. Use your own.

The middle is 3 times as thick.

The zoomed-in box: a close-up of the shaft wall with a dashed yellow line across it and two red click marks

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/bonetissue, Tab 1

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 4 AND 5

The drop test

1

Read Question 4 first. What changes? What is measured? What stays the same?

2

Press Drop on the solid wall. Watch the timer.

3

Press Drop on the spongy end.

4

Do each one twice. Write 60+ if the drop is still there at 60 s.

LIVE LAB · TAB 1

New tab

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

The parts of a long bone

The long middle is the diaphysis (the shaft). Each end is an epiphysis. The empty channel in the shaft is the medullary cavity. In life it is full of soft marrow.

A human thigh bone sawn across its shaft. A thick pale ring of solid bone surrounds a dark hollow in the middle

Photo: MAKY.OREL, Charles University, CC0

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Compact bone

The thick, solid wall of the shaft is compact bone. It has almost no open space. A thick, solid tube is hard to bend or twist. That is its job.

A human thigh bone sawn across its shaft. A thick pale ring of solid bone surrounds a dark hollow in the middle

Photo: MAKY.OREL, Charles University, CC0

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Spongy bone

The inside of the end is spongy bone: a lattice of thin, hard plates with spaces between them. Only a thin shell of compact bone covers it.

The neck of a human thigh bone cut across. A thin pale rim surrounds red bone full of tiny holes, with a yellow patch in the middle

Photo: Steven Fruitsmaak, public domain

PART 1 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Why the water vanished

On the solid wall, the drop sat on top. On the spongy end, it soaked in within seconds. In a living bone, those spaces hold red marrow, which makes blood cells.

The round end of an upper arm bone cut across: a thin pale shell around red spongy bone, with a yellow patch in the middle

Photo: OpenStax, CC BY 4.0

PART 1 · QUESTIONS 6 AND 7

Name it

QUESTION 6

Wall · End · Channel

Three names

The solid wall of the shaft is ___ bone.

The inside of the end is ___ bone.

The empty channel is the ___.

QUESTION 7

60+ s vs 3 s

Where did the water go?

In a living bone, what fills those spaces?

What does it make?

A microscope view of compact bone: tan rings of bone around small round holes, with dark specks between the rings

TAB 2 · QUESTIONS 8 TO 13

Part 2. Under the microscope

The same two tissues, about 100 times bigger.

Count how much is hard bone. Then measure one osteon.

Photo: Lord of Konrad, CC0

PART 2 · QUESTION 8

Count the points

1

Pick Compact. Click every ring that sits on hard bone.

2

A ring inside a canal (the hole in the middle of a ring pattern) is open space. Dark specks count as bone.

3

Press Check my count. Then do Spongy: the purple plates are bone.

4

Each point is worth 4%, because 100 ÷ 25 = 4.

LIVE LAB · TAB 2

New tab

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 9 AND 10

Measure an osteon

1

Click the yellow O line, or the Osteon A button.

2

In the zoomed box, click one edge of the ring pattern, then the other.

3

Do the same for Canal A, the hole in its middle.

4

Write the lab’s numbers. 1,000 µm = 1 mm.

The lab: compact bone with a grid of rings, some ticked, and two yellow measuring lines across one ring pattern; spongy bone with purple plates and its own rings

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/bonetissue, Tab 2

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 4

Osteons

Compact bone is built of osteons: rings of hard bone matrix around a tube. Each ring is a thin layer. One osteon is about as wide as two hairs, and long like a pencil.

A microscope view of compact bone: tan rings of bone around small round holes, with dark specks between the rings

Photo: Lord of Konrad, CC0

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 4

Canal and cells

The tube in the middle is the central canal. It carries blood vessels and nerves. The dark specks are tiny spaces, each holding a bone cell, an osteocyte. Thin channels link them to the canal.

A microscope view of compact bone: tan rings of bone around small round holes, with dark specks between the rings

Photo: Lord of Konrad, CC0

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 4

Trabeculae

The purple plates in spongy bone are trabeculae. Between them is marrow: big white fat cells and small blue blood-making cells.

A microscope view of spongy bone: purple branching plates with pale marrow full of small blue dots and white round fat cells between them

Photo: Nataliia Maryenko, CC BY-SA 4.0

PART 2 · LEARN IT · 4 OF 4

Spongy is not soft

Spongy bone is the same hard material as compact bone, built as a lattice instead of a block. Compact bone is less than 5% open space. In spongy bone, only about 20% of the space is bone.

A yellow bath sponge full of round holes

Photo: Robert Fotograf, CC0

PART 2 · QUESTIONS 12 AND 13

Use the idea

QUESTION 12

Soft?

"Spongy bone is soft, like a kitchen sponge."

Agree or disagree?

Give one piece of evidence from the lab.

QUESTION 13

Shaft · Ends

Structure and function

Why is compact bone in the shaft?

Why is spongy bone in the ends?

Name one job for each.

A slice through a vertebra with osteoporosis: a few thin white struts with large dark spaces between them

TAB 3 · QUESTIONS 14 TO 17

Part 3. Bone loss over a lifetime

Bone is alive. Cells take it away and build it up all the time.

Which parts of the skeleton lose the most bone with age?

Photo: Turner Biomechanics Laboratory, CC0

PART 3

Two vertebrae

A slice through a healthy vertebra: a dense white mesh of fine bone plates

Healthy. A man of 37.

A slice through a vertebra with osteoporosis: a few thin white struts with large dark spaces between them

Osteoporosis. A woman of 75.

Photos: Turner Biomechanics Laboratory, CC0

PART 3 · QUESTIONS 14 AND 15

Record three people

1

Pick Woman. Set the age to 50. Press Record this person.

2

Set the age to 90. Record.

3

Pick Man. Set 90. Record.

4

Which site lost the most? Look at how much of each site is spongy.

LIVE LAB · TAB 3

New tab

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 1 OF 3

Osteoporosis

Osteoporosis means "porous bone." With age, cells take away more bone than they build. The bone gets lighter, full of bigger holes, and breaks more easily.

A slice through a vertebra with osteoporosis: a few thin white struts with large dark spaces between them

Photo: Turner Biomechanics Laboratory, CC0

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 2 OF 3

Spongy bone goes first

Spongy bone has much more surface touching the marrow, where bone cells work. In a large study, people lost spongy bone from young adulthood on. Compact bone loss started in middle age.

A slice through a healthy vertebra: a dense white mesh of fine bone plates

Photo: Turner Biomechanics Laboratory, CC0

PART 3 · LEARN IT · 3 OF 3

Hip, spine and wrist

About 1 in 2 women and 1 in 4 men over 50 will break a bone from osteoporosis, most often the hip, spine or wrist. All three are spongy-rich. The wrist break is at the end of the radius.

Three X-rays of a wrist. A circle marks a break in the end of the radius, just above the wrist

Photo: Ashish j29, CC BY 3.0

PART 3 · QUESTION 16

Model check

The model uses

Two real numbers for each site. Name them.

It leaves out

Name one thing about real people the model does not include.

Hint

Think about what makes one person’s bones different from another’s.

The lab: two vertebra slices on the left, and three site cards on the right for the forearm shaft, the hip and the spine, each with a compact and spongy bar and a bone-left number

Screenshot: mrsajdak.com/bonetissue, Tab 3, a woman of 60

EXPLAIN IT · QUESTION 17

Why the hip, the spine and the wrist?

What I saw

One thing you measured or watched today.

The science idea

Where spongy bone is, and what osteoporosis does to it.

So

How that explains where the breaks happen.

Three X-rays of a wrist. A circle marks a break in the end of the radius, just above the wrist

A broken wrist: the end of the radius.

Photo: Ashish j29, CC BY 3.0

WRAP IT UP · BACK TO THE START

Revisiting the Phenomenon

Why is one bone built two ways: solid in the middle, full of holes at the ends?

1Using evidence from today, explain why the middle of the femur is a solid tube.

2Why is the end full of holes? Is it weaker, or just built differently?

3What lives in the holes in a living person?

4Which numbers from your worksheet best support your explanation?

A human thigh bone sawn across its shaft. A thick pale ring of solid bone surrounds a dark hollow in the middle

Cut A: the shaft. Compact bone.

The neck of a human thigh bone cut across. A thin pale rim surrounds red bone full of tiny holes, with a yellow patch in the middle

Cut B: near the hip. Spongy bone inside.

Photos: MAKY.OREL, Charles University, CC0 · Steven Fruitsmaak, public domain

The round end of an upper arm bone cut across: a thin pale shell around red spongy bone, with a yellow patch in the middle

LAST CHECK

Before you hand it in

Name, date and period are on top.

Every table is full.

Question 4 has one tick in each row.

Question 17 has all three parts.

Photo: OpenStax, CC BY 4.0