Why can't a population grow forever? Run four real cases and find out what holds each one back.
Finish these steps in the lab. Then this box opens.
When nothing holds a population back, more plants make even more plants. The bigger it gets, the faster it grows. The line bends up like the letter J. This is called exponential growth.
Real populations run into limits. Growth slows down as the pond fills up. Then it stops. The line looks like the letter S. This is called logistic growth.
The level where an S-curve stops is the carrying capacity. It is the largest population a place can support over time. In the lab it is the dotted red line.
A limiting factor keeps a population from growing bigger. Food, water, space, light and nutrients can all be limiting factors. Give a population more of what limits it, and the carrying capacity goes up. Look at your table. Which runs ended higher?
Some limits hit harder when a population is crowded. These are density-dependent factors. Running out of space or food is one. Disease is another, because it spreads faster in a crowd.
Other limits kill the same share of a population, crowded or not. These are density-independent factors. A flood or a wildfire is one.
Now answer Q3 and Q4 on your worksheet.
Finish these steps in the lab. Then this box opens.
In winter, reindeer eat lichen. Lichen grows back very slowly. A grazed patch can take decades to grow back. The island's carrying capacity is the most reindeer the lichen can feed year after year. It is the orange dotted line.
In 1944, the lichen on the island had been growing for many years with nothing eating it. A herd can eat a stored food supply faster than it grows back. So for a while, the herd can grow past the carrying capacity. Growing past the carrying capacity is called overshoot.
Overshoot cannot last. When the stored food is gone, the habitat cannot feed the herd. Many animals die in a short time. This is a population crash.
A hard winter is density-independent. Food is density-dependent. To find the real limit, scientists take one factor away and see if the crash still happens. Compare your run with the hard winter and your run without it.
Predators are a density-dependent limit. When prey are crowded, predators catch more of them. When prey are few, predators catch fewer. This can hold a population near a steady number, below the carrying capacity.
Now answer Q8 and Q9 on your worksheet.
Finish these steps in the lab. Then this box opens.
Every living thing can survive only in a certain range of conditions. This is its range of tolerance. It is true for temperature, light, water and pH. Too little can limit a population. So can too much.
In the optimum range, living things do best. Next to it on each side is a zone of stress. Some survive there, but they grow and reproduce poorly. Past that is the zone of intolerance. Nothing survives there.
pH tells how acidic water is. A pH of 7 is neutral. Lower numbers are more acidic. Each step down is 10 times more acidic. Burning coal and oil puts sulfur and nitrogen gases into the air. They mix with rain and make acid rain. Many Adirondack lakes sit on thin soil and hard rock that cannot cancel out much acid, so the lakes turned acidic.
To show that one thing causes another, change only that one thing. Keep everything else the same. This is a controlled experiment. If only one thing was different, the different results must come from that one thing.
Now answer Q12 and Q13 on your worksheet.
Finish these steps in the lab. Then this box opens.
A survivorship curve shows how many of a group are still alive at each age. There are three types.
Late loss: most live to old age, then die. People are an example.
Constant loss: about the same share die at every age.
Early loss: most die very young. The few that survive can live a long time. Sea turtles are an example.
The survivorship graph uses a log scale. Each gridline is 10 times the one below it. On this kind of graph, a straight line sloping down means the same share die at every age.
An r-selected species has many young and gives them little or no care. Most of the young die. The ones that live grow up fast and breed early. After a bad year, the population can grow back quickly.
A K-selected species has few young and takes care of them. More of the young survive. They grow up slowly and live a long time. (K is the symbol for carrying capacity.) After a big loss, the population comes back slowly.
A population that recovers slowly stays small for years. While it is small, one more bad year or disease can wipe it out.
Now finish the Q14 table and answer Q15 on your worksheet.
Follow-along slideshow · 45 slides that open with the St. Matthew Island phenomenon, teach each part with Learn It slides, and walk through the worksheet, question by question
Printable student worksheet (PDF) · two pages, goes with this lab
Low-write worksheet (PDF) · same questions with tick boxes, word banks and worked examples
Teacher guide: NYSSLS, SEP and CCC alignment (PDF)
What you will learn. Day 1: I can use a pond model's numbers to tell exponential (J-curve) growth from logistic (S-curve) growth. I can use the St. Matthew Island reindeer numbers to explain overshoot and a population crash. Day 2: I can use survival numbers to find a range of tolerance and say why too much or too little limits. I can match survivorship curves to r- and K-selected species and say which is most at risk.
These are models. Real populations also go up and down with weather, disease and luck. The models leave those out so every run gives the same answer. The reindeer model is tuned to the real island counts; the pond, tank and life-strategy numbers are made up to show the patterns. Environmental Science, Chapter 5, Lesson 5.3: What Limits the Growth of Populations?
© 2026 Ryan Sajdak. This lab, its worksheets and its slides are free to use, share and change under the Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 license: give credit, do not sell it, and share your version the same way. Photos and 3D models made by other people keep their own licenses.